Steady Stoic
Daily lesson · Week 36 · Friday · Afternoon

Human Nature

This week's concept is human nature, and specifically what the Stoics believed human nature actually is. The Stoics held that every person is born with the capacity for reason and virtue, but that we arrive at wrongdoing through ignorance, poor upbringing, and the habits we absorb from those around us. Understanding this is the foundation of patience with others: when you see clearly why people do harm, indignation starts to lose its grip. The traditional term for the rational, social nature the Stoics saw in every person is "koinonia" in Greek, or more broadly what they called living "kata phusin," meaning according to nature. You will meet that idea here in plain terms as the week unfolds.

Passage

From this we come to realize that since Nature is the source of right, it is not in accord with Nature that anyone should take advantage of his neighbour's ignorance. And no greater curse in life can be found than knavery that wears the mask of wisdom. Thence come those countless cases in which the expedient seems to conflict with the right. For how few will be found who can refrain from wrong-doing, if assured of the power to keep it an absolute secret and to run no risk of punishment!

— Cicero, On Duties 3.72

Reflection

Cicero introduces a darker complication. Nature is the source of right, he says, and exploiting another person's ignorance violates nature, because it turns their shared rational nature into a tool for your advantage. This is the shadow side of everything the week has built. Understanding human nature, that people act from limited knowledge, is meant to generate compassion, not manipulation. The person who uses another's ignorance for personal gain is, in Cicero's sharp phrase, wearing wisdom as a mask over knavery. Today's facet: patience with others is only as good as the honesty behind it. Seeing people's limitations clearly must go hand in hand with treating them fairly.

Go deeper

Are there situations in your daily life, at work, in close relationships, anywhere, where your awareness of someone else's blind spots tempts you to take advantage rather than to help?

Practice

Honesty Check

About 5 minutes

Sit quietly for five minutes. Ask yourself honestly: is there any relationship or situation right now where you are using someone's naivety or ignorance to your own benefit, even in a small way? Write one sentence naming it plainly, without self-justification. Then write one sentence naming what acting in accord with their good, not just your advantage, would actually look like.